Ask three separate questions. Why do I have to pay extra? What exactly are we agreeing to exchange? Is money being bet on a gamble? Riba, gharar and maysir are different concerns, though one deal can have more than one of them. A fee, a possible loss or an unknown future profit does not answer these questions by itself.
Three questions, then read the contract
What this guide covers: It explains one common kind of riba: a benefit that a lender is promised because they lent money. It does not cover every riba rule. For example, there are special rules for exchanging money, gold and some other commodities. For terms not covered here, our contract glossary is a good place to start.
Riba, gharar and maysir mean more than just “risky”. Ask:
- Why does an extra payment arise?
- Are the rights being exchanged, and how they will be delivered, seriously unclear?
- Are people putting up stakes so that one gains from another’s lost stake?
Then read the whole contract. A clear document can still contain a feature Shariah does not allow. And a confusing explanation needs to be cleared up before anyone can say whether a deal follows Shariah. The ruling on loan benefits used here comes from Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) and its Shariah Advisory Council (SAC).1 The definitions come from a glossary by the Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB), an international standard-setter.2
Three different questions
- RibaWhy is more owed?
For a loan of money, look for a benefit the lender is promised because of the loan. Do not judge from the word “fee”.1
- GhararWhat exactly is being exchanged?
Look for serious uncertainty about the item, the price, the delivery or what you are entitled to. Not knowing how much a business will sell tomorrow is a different question.2,3
- MaysirWhat is the bet?
Find the stake, the event and the prize. Does one person’s gain come from another person’s lost stake? Losing money on an investment is not enough on its own.2,3
Text description of this figure
Each card asks its own question. Riba asks why an extra amount is owed. Gharar asks what is uncertain in the exchange. Maysir asks what is being bet and where the prize money comes from. One deal can raise more than one of these concerns.
| In plain words | Everyday example to question | Not automatically a problem | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Riba | Extra money a lender gets because of the loan | A friend lends you RM500 only if you pay back RM550 | A shop selling a fridge on instalments at a price above its cost |
| Gharar | Serious uncertainty about what you get or pay | Paying now for “a surprise item, value to be decided later” | Not knowing what a business will earn next year |
| Maysir | Gambling: your win comes from someone else’s lost bet | Paying RM10 into a pool where a coin toss decides who takes it all | Buying shares that later fall in price |
BNM’s SAC made a decision on 30 March 2016 about qard, a loan of money. As a general rule, the lender may not receive a benefit, set in the contract, that depends on the loan or comes from the loan amount. There is an exception: a general benefit, offered to everyone and not written into the loan terms. So ask what a charge pays for and why it arises. Calling it an “administration fee” does not settle the question.1
Paying more than cost is not automatically riba
Imagine a Malaysian family buying a fridge from a shop that already owns it. Below is a very simple sale at cost plus profit. Now compare it with someone handing you cash on condition that you pay back more because you borrowed. The amounts may look alike. But what is exchanged, and what creates the debt, are different.2
This example shows one sale of an appliance. It is not the two-sale tawarruq deal that gives you cash, which we look at later.
A made-up fridge sale, step by step
- The shop owns the fridge
A specific fridge is ready to deliver. Say it cost the shop RM1,000. Ask for a description of it, and check that the shop can deliver it.
- The fridge becomes yours; the price becomes your debt
You agree to pay RM1,200 in total, including RM200 profit that the shop tells you about. Find out when you take possession and when the fridge becomes your responsibility. This is a sale, not a cash loan.
- You pay the shop 12 × RM100
The payment dates are fixed. The fridge’s resale value, or your income, may change. Those risks do not make the agreed price unknown.
Text description of this figure
First the shop owns the fridge. The sale passes ownership to the buyer and creates a RM1,200 debt. Twelve payments of RM100 pay off that price. The diagram separates a sale price from extra money charged on a loan. It cannot show that any real sale follows Shariah.
BNM’s tawarruq policy sets clear rules.4
- The asset must be real, identifiable and deliverable, and the seller must own it.
- The buyer must take possession before selling it on. Possession can be physical (you hold it) or constructive (you control it and carry its risk without holding it).
- The rules allow some agency arrangements, where someone buys or sells on your behalf.
Even so, an asset’s name on a form does not prove a trade really happened. Ask for the trade records and for who did what at each sale.4
Not every institution agrees. In 2009, the International Islamic Fiqh Academy (IIFA) treated the classic form of tawarruq differently from organised versions arranged by banks. It objected to some organised forms.8 That position is separate from BNM’s Malaysian rules. Neither source proves that a particular bank carried out its own trades correctly.

Unclear terms are not the same as an uncertain result
A business result you cannot predict is not automatically gambling. Ask:
- Where does the stake come from?
- What can each person gain or lose?
- Does the payout depend on someone else losing their stake?
- Are the rights being exchanged, and how they are delivered, clear enough?
The IFSB glossary describes gharar as uncertainty in a sale, and maysir as gambling.2 Economist Sami Al-Suwailem’s work helps to tell ordinary risk apart from the way gains and losses are arranged in a deal. We do not use it as a fixed number test for every case.3 The type of contract, the whole arrangement and how serious the uncertainty is all still matter.
Ordinary risk, and the feature to look at
Investors know the business, the money put in and how profit will be shared. The actual profit is uncertain, and they may lose some of their money.
No formula, asset, entitlement or delivery terms are given. The concern is the missing promise, not just that the result can vary.
Earning no profit is not the same as losing a bet. It still matters who bears a normal loss, and who bears a loss caused by misconduct.
A coin toss decides who takes both stakes. The winner gets RM20 back (a RM10 gain). The loser loses RM10. Nothing else, no goods or service, is exchanged.
A falling price alone tells you nothing certain about the contract’s Shariah features. Check the activity, who owns what and the trading terms.
Margin is the RM1,000 deposit you put down. Exposure is the bigger RM10,000 position whose price moves decide your gain or loss. A 5% move against you means a RM500 loss before costs, half your deposit. Your margin is not the most you can lose. Ask what you actually own or are owed, the financing charge, who is on the other side and when your position can be closed. This is not a model of anyone’s real trade.
Text description of this figure
Each row compares two different situations; it does not label products safe or unsafe. A business can fail even when everyone’s rights are clear. An unclear payout has no agreed entitlement. Two people staking RM10 each make a RM20 pool: the winner gains RM10 and the loser loses RM10. In the leverage example, RM10,000 × 5% = RM500, half the RM1,000 margin before costs. Leverage on its own is not proof of maysir.
If a payout promise is unclear, get the terms in writing. What do you own? Who owes you money? What formula decides the payment, and when is it due? Who bears a loss? Publishing the odds does not turn a bet into an investment. On the other hand, a business can set out everyone’s rights clearly and still not be able to promise its future sales.
What real Malaysian documents show
HSBC Amanah’s product disclosure sheet (PDS), dated September 2026, describes a deal made of two commodity sales.5 Its March 2026 terms appoint the bank as your agent to buy and to resell.6 It works like this:
- The bank sells commodities to you.
- As your agent, the bank sells them on for cash straight away, and the cash is paid to you.
- You owe the bank its selling price. A rebate (ibra’) set out in the documents can reduce what you actually pay.5,6
This is the bank’s public description. It does not show that the trades were carried out.
Ask about costs separately. The September PDS says:5
- a late-payment charge of 1% a year on the overdue amount, worked out daily; and
- stamp duty of 0.5% on the financing amount, but only if the financing needs collateral. There may also be separate duty on the security documents.
The March terms set out other late-payment stages and how each is worked out.6 So the short PDS summary is not the full account calculation. Do not apply these charges to the made-up fridge sale. And do not assume that every charge is riba.
A contract for difference (CFD) pays out the change in an asset’s price without you owning the asset. It can expose you to market swings without ownership. Check what you are staking, what right you get, and what financing or closing charges can arise. How it works does not, by itself, settle whether it follows Shariah.
Note on CFDs (a specialised product)
Phillip Capital’s July 2026 CFD disclosure describes leveraged exposure without ownership, daily finance charges on positions held overnight, and positions that may be closed for you.9 Both that document and the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) guidelines limit CFDs to sophisticated investors (people who meet set wealth or income levels).9,10 We include this only as a note. It is not a product for beginners and not an endorsement.
Muslim or not, you need the same facts
HSBC Amanah’s financing FAQ says its product is open to eligible Muslims and non-Muslims.7 That is one example. It does not mean everyone is approved, or that every Islamic product has the same rule.
A Muslim may want to be sure the deal follows Shariah. A non-Muslim may compare cost and service. Both need to understand what they will owe and what they could lose. This guide cannot judge whether a product suits you, and it does not issue a new fatwa (religious ruling).

Questions to ask the provider
- What kind of contract is this: a loan, a sale, a lease, a partnership or a price-difference contract? Ask for the document that applies and the version printed on it.
- List the money you receive, any asset or benefit you get, the total you owe and every separate fee. What causes each payment?
- Who owns the asset, and can they deliver it? If an agent trades for you, where are the records of the purchase, possession and resale?
- Which terms are still unclear: amount, quality, date, formula, what triggers a claim, who bears a loss or how to cancel? Ask for a written explanation.
- Is there a stake and a prize paid from the stakes that lost? If it is an investment, what real business activity and rights are involved?
- Which Shariah decision or framework covers this exact deal and the way it is carried out? A marketing name, or a diagram like ours, is not enough.
If the provider’s written answer does not match the product documents, keep both and ask the provider to explain the difference. Details missing from this guide are simply missing evidence. They do not prove that a particular deal is allowed or not allowed.
Spotting a bad deal
- Promised a fixed, high return from a “Shariah-compliant” scheme? Be very careful: high, fixed returns with “no risk” are a common sign of a scam. Check the SC Investor Alert List and ask which licensed company runs it.
- Already sent money and think it was a scam? Call the National Scam Response Centre at 997 straight away.
- Finding it hard to keep up with financing payments? AKPK, the credit counselling agency set up by BNM, gives free advice.
- A dispute with your bank or takaful operator? Use its complaints process first. If you are still unhappy, the Financial Markets Ombudsman Service (FMOS) is free for you, but it has limits and deadlines.
References
We reopened the original sources from their publishers on 6 October 2026. The dates printed below are the documents’ own dates, not the date we checked them. The older research explains ideas. Public documents do not prove how a deal was carried out or what happened for any customer. The PDFs stay on their publishers’ websites.
Title: SAC 167th Meeting — contractual benefit to lender in qard
Publisher and date: Bank Negara Malaysia · Meeting 30 March 2016; historical resolution
Sections checked: Contractual benefit to the lender in a qard contract
Limitation: Loan-benefit ruling with general/non-exclusive benefit exception; not a complete riba taxonomy.
Title: Islamic Financial Services Industry Stability Report 2013
Publisher and date: Islamic Financial Services Board · Report 2013; hosting path 2023 is not an effective date
Sections checked: Glossary PDF pp.7–8: gharar, maysir, mudarabah
Limitation: Historical glossary and loss-sharing counterexample; not a current product ruling.
Title: Towards an Objective Measure of Gharar in Exchange — Sami Al-Suwailem
Publisher and date: Journal of Islamic Business and Management (authorised republication) · Original IRTI Islamic Economic Studies 7(1–2), Oct 1999/Apr 2000, pp.61–102; reprinted JIBM 2(1), 2012
Sections checked: PDF pp.1,4–6; §§2.4,3,3.1
Limitation: Economic/game-theory interpretation; attributed, not a universal automated test or new fatwa.
Title: Tawarruq policy document
Publisher and date: Bank Negara Malaysia · Issued/effective 28 December 2018; still listed by policy register on access date
Sections checked: §§4.1,9–14,16; §§13.1,13.7–13.11,25.14
Limitation: Malaysian framework; mandatory standards differ from guidance; no individual transaction audit.
Title: Personal Financing Product Disclosure Sheet
Publisher and date: HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Sep2026; customer date blank; effective date not separately stated
Sections checked: pp.1–2: concept, obligations, charges, risks
Limitation: Public illustration, not a quotation; collateral stamp-duty condition retained; late-payment summary not all stages.
Title: Personal Financing-i Terms and Conditions
Publisher and date: HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Mar26; effective date not separately stated
Sections checked: §§4–5,7,9–10,12–14
Limitation: Agency/selling-price/rebate description; other-stage late-payment base differs; actual approval advice and execution unavailable.
Title: Personal Financing-i FAQ
Publisher and date: HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Undated live FAQ
Sections checked: Is this personal financing for Muslim customers only?; processing fee
Limitation: Eligible Muslims and non-Muslims; no personal approval or universal eligibility. Public thresholds differ from landing page and are omitted.
Title: Resolution 179 (5/19): Essence and Types of Tawaruq
Publisher and date: International Islamic Fiqh Academy · Session 26–30 April 2009; page dated 30 April 2009
Sections checked: First: types; Second: structured and inverse tawarruq
Limitation: Historical issuer-specific position, distinct from Malaysian BNM framework; no claim of worldwide consensus.
Title: Contracts for Difference Disclosure Document
Publisher and date: Phillip Capital Sdn Bhd · First issued 28 June 2019; seventh revision and revision effective 16 July 2026 (printed pp.1–2)
Sections checked: pp.1–2; §3 investor participation; §4.1; §§6.1,6.10,6.12,6.16; §7.4
Limitation: Current linked public mechanics/access, not a personal eligibility decision or Shariah certificate. No tariff quoted; fictional model is not its margin schedule. Live landing and PDF financing rates can differ, so obtain applicable tariff.
Title: Guidelines on Contracts for Difference
Publisher and date: Securities Commission Malaysia · Current register link: revised 14 June 2024; printed revision/effective date checked
Sections checked: Revision table R3-2024; §§3.10–3.11; §4.02
Limitation: Regulatory framework is separate from a Shariah determination. February 2024 PDF found in search is superseded and not used for current rules.
Title: Lembaran Pendedahan Produk — Pembiayaan Peribadi HSBC Amanah
Publisher and date: HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Sep2026; customer date blank; effective date not separately stated
Sections checked: pp.1–2: concept, obligations, charges, risks
Limitation: Public illustration, not a quotation; collateral stamp-duty condition retained; late-payment summary not all stages.
Title: Terma dan Syarat Pembiayaan Peribadi-i
Publisher and date: HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Mac 26 (Malay original, March 2026); effective date not separately stated
Sections checked: §§4–5,7,9–10,12–14
Limitation: Agency/selling-price/rebate description; other-stage late-payment base differs; actual approval advice and execution unavailable.
