The short answer: BNM and the SC set the rules, and each runs a national Shariah Advisory Council (SAC) whose rulings apply in its area. Each Islamic bank and takaful operator must also have its own Shariah committee. Its board and managers must make sure the rules are followed, and staff check, review and audit the work. For investments, advisers registered with the SC play a similar role. Several layers share the work, and each answers a different question.
Start with the product and the provider
Say you are comparing Islamic personal financing with an Islamic unit trust. Both use Shariah words. But they do different jobs, and different rules and regulators cover them.2,3 Before you ask who checked a product, find out three things:
- the provider’s legal name;
- the contract; and
- what the product actually does.
If a bank sells you an investment, that investment does not become a bank deposit.9
Two terms help:
- Shariah compliance means the product’s structure and activities meet the Shariah requirements that apply to it.
- Shariah governance means who decides, who carries the decision out, who keeps watch and who fixes mistakes.
When you read a Shariah statement, check which product it names, what period it covers and what it includes. A Shariah logo on an advert tells you much less.
Who checks what?
Do not treat the two national councils as one. A bank’s own Shariah committee also has a different job from a regulator’s council. The bank’s board and managers keep their own duties. Hiring Shariah advisers does not hand every duty over to them.1
Figure 1
Who checks what?
Malaysia • Two separate areas. A simple summary of duties, not an organisation chart for every provider.
BNM and its SAC
SC and its SAC
The bank’s own Shariah committee
Shariah risk, review and audit
Shariah adviser for investments
You: check the evidence
| If you have… | Regulator | National Shariah council | Shariah checks inside the provider |
|---|---|---|---|
| Islamic savings account, home or car financing, personal financing-i, Islamic credit card | BNM | BNM’s SAC | The bank’s Shariah committee, plus its risk, review and audit teams |
| Family takaful, medical takaful, motor takaful | BNM | BNM’s SAC | The takaful operator’s Shariah committee, plus its risk, review and audit teams |
| Islamic unit trust, sukuk, Shariah-compliant shares | SC | SC’s SAC | A Shariah adviser where SC rules require one; the SC’s list for listed shares |
This table is our simple guide. Some products and providers have special arrangements, so check the documents for your own product.

A check at the start is not the whole process
A product can be designed correctly and still go wrong in practice. It needs to be carried out properly and checked all the time. BNM’s Shariah Governance policy covers the institutions it names. These include licensed Islamic banks, takaful and retakaful operators, approved Islamic banking “windows” (Islamic units inside conventional banks) and some other prescribed institutions. Most of the policy took effect on 1 April 2020. Paragraph 12.5 took effect on 1 April 2023.1
Investment products follow the SC rules that apply to them. Those rules differ from the BNM process shown below.3
For professionals: the 2026 SC update
The diagram below is a summary for readers. It is not a fixed order that every launch must follow. The SC revised its guidelines (version R2-2026) on 30 March 2026.3 The change to paragraph 7.03 is about the deadline for some advisers to send in their existing yearly declaration. It applies from 1 January 2027.11 Transition rules still apply until then.12
Figure 2
From an idea to ongoing checks
Institutions under BNM • A simple picture of the process; real arrangements differ by institution and activity.
1 · Explain the idea
2 · Decide and carry out
3 · Watch what really happens
4 · Report, fix and disclose
Follow a real financing document
HSBC Amanah’s published terms give the bank two separate roles in its personal financing.7,6
- As seller, the bank sells you a Shariah-compliant commodity at an agreed price, the “Bank Selling Price”. You pay it later, in instalments.
- As your buying agent, under a separate appointment, the bank does what is needed to complete your purchase. You now own the commodity.
- As your selling agent, the bank sells your commodity to a third party for cash and gives you the money.
- You still owe the bank the Bank Selling Price, less any rebate (ibra’) set out in the terms.
These public documents explain the contract. They do not prove how any single trade was carried out.
Ask the provider to match up three documents for your offer: the PDS, the Approval Advice (the approval letter) and the agreement. Then ask where it publishes its Shariah governance information. The public documents do not show that every single deal was audited.6,7 The bank’s FAQ says eligible Muslims and non-Muslims can apply. It does not promise approval to either group.8
Four checks, four different questions
Shariah governance matters. But if you treat it as a safety guarantee, big questions go unanswered. Keep these four things apart: Shariah compliance, the licence to operate, whether you qualify, and the money risk.
Figure 3
Shariah, licence, eligibility and money risk
Different evidence for different questions • No check below covers the others.
Shariah check
Licence or registration
Whether you qualify
Risk, affordability and protection
PIDM (Perbadanan Insurans Deposit Malaysia) is the government agency that protects eligible deposits at its member banks, up to a set limit, if a bank fails. Its website lists the limits and which products are not covered.9
What the “Shariah” label does not settle
- A financing customer can still pay fees and late-payment charges, and the bank can still take action to recover money owed.
- A takaful claim can still fall outside what the certificate covers.
- A Shariah-compliant share can still fall in value.6,4
None of these, on its own, proves a Shariah breach. They are about different evidence and different duties. Buy now, pay later (BNPL) providers may also fall under different rules from Islamic banks. See which Shariah ideas may apply to Malaysian BNPL.
If you have a dispute about a payment or a claim, use the provider’s complaints process, then the right dispute service (see below). A regulator’s Shariah Advisory Council does not handle refunds for customers. If you have a Shariah question about how your product works, ask the provider to point to the contract clause and explain how it was applied.
Five steps to check a product:
- Find the provider’s legal name and what the product does, not just the brand.
- Ask which Shariah committee or adviser, and which rules, support the product.
- Read the dated PDS and the agreement, takaful certificate or prospectus.
- Check what you receive or own, what you owe and what can be excluded.
- Check the money risks and protection separately. Keep written answers, and use the provider’s complaints process if you need to.

Research background and credits
ISRA’s past research gives useful background. But the explanation on this page is based on BNM and SC documents.
Dated credit
An INCEIF announcement dated 25 January 2023 names Ashraf Md Hashim and Marjan Muhammad. It describes their appointments to BNM’s council and their ISRA research and consulting roles at that time. This is not a biography or a current list of council members. It also does not mean that any earlier ISRA council oversees this independent guide.10
If something goes wrong
- A dispute with your bank or takaful operator? Complain to the provider in writing first. If you are still unhappy, the Financial Markets Ombudsman Service (FMOS) is free for you, but it has limits and deadlines. Our complaints guide explains the steps.
- Struggling with financing payments? AKPK, the credit counselling agency set up by BNM, gives free advice.
- Offered a “Shariah-compliant” investment by a company you cannot find on a regulator’s list? Check the SC Investor Alert List and BNM’s Financial Consumer Alert List. If you have already sent money and think it is a scam, call the National Scam Response Centre at 997 straight away.
References
This is a new plain-language explanation based on the linked original documents. Where a document prints a date, we use that date rather than the date in its file name. Provider examples cover only the named documents and are not endorsements. The PDFs stay on their publishers’ websites. The “Read next” links go to pages on this site.
- BNM: Shariah GovernanceBank Negara Malaysia · Issued 20 September 2019; effective 1 April 2020, except 12.5: 1 April 2023 · 2, 4, 5.2, 8–10, 15–19, 22
- BNM: Shariah Advisory CouncilBank Negara Malaysia · Live page; date not stated · SAC introduction and scope
- SC: Guidelines on Islamic Capital Market Products and ServicesSecurities Commission Malaysia · R2-2026 revised/effective 30 March 2026; 7.03 submission deadline changes from 1 January 2027 · Revision table; 7.03 and footnote 2; Chapters 6, 22–23; 13, 16–18
- SC: Shariah-Compliant SecuritiesSecurities Commission Malaysia · Live page; accessed 6 October 2026 · Screening methodology; lists
- SC: Registered Shariah AdvisersSecurities Commission Malaysia · Live page; date not stated · Definition; appointment; register
- HSBC Amanah: Personal Financing PDSHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · v.Sep2026; customer date field blank · pp. 1–2: structure, obligations, risks and contacts
- HSBC Amanah: Personal Financing-i termsHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · v.Mar26 · 4–5: agency and commodity transactions; 7, 9–10: payments and rebate
- HSBC Amanah: Personal Financing-i FAQHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Undated live FAQ · Is this personal financing for Muslim customers only?
- PIDM: Deposit Insurance SystemPerbadanan Insurans Deposit Malaysia · Live page; date not stated · Eligible deposits; limits; excluded products
- INCEIF: dated research and council contextINCEIF University · 25 January 2023 · Dated announcement naming Ashraf Md Hashim and Marjan Muhammad
- SC: Summary of Amendments, ICMPSSecurities Commission Malaysia · Issued/revised 30 March 2026 · p. 3: paragraph 7.03 deadline change
- SC: ICMPS Frequently Asked QuestionsSecurities Commission Malaysia · Issued/revised 30 March 2026 · Q19: annual-declaration transitional requirements
