Maqasid means the purposes, or objectives, of Shariah. In finance, it asks what the whole system should achieve for people: wealth that moves around in useful ways, fair dealings and justice. For your own decision, ask three things. Is the contract set up properly? Do you understand the payments, and can you manage them? What evidence backs up the promised benefit? These questions are linked, but each one needs its own evidence.
Whose framework are we using?
Maqasid asks two things: what finance should achieve (the ends) and how it should get there (the means). We use a framework by Mohamad Akram Laldin and Hafas Furqani, published in 2013.1
- The ends: wealth that circulates in useful ways; fair and transparent (open) financial practices; and justice for each person and for society.
- The means: workable contracts; shared values and standards; and social responsibility.
For example, financing an essential household item can serve a useful purpose. But that purpose alone is not enough. The contract must be sound. The customer must understand the payments and be able to manage them. And any claim of a wider benefit needs evidence.
Where this summary comes from
It is based on the public summary (abstract) of the authors’ 2013 paper. The paper is Developing Islamic finance in the framework of maqasid al-Shari’ah: Understanding the ends (maqasid) and the means (wasa’il). It appeared in volume 6(4), pages 278–289, DOI 10.1108/IMEFM-05-2013-0057. We could not open the full paper, which is behind a paywall. The authors’ job titles on the publisher’s page are from 2013, not their current roles.1
Ends, means and results
- Framework · endsWhat should be achieved?
Wealth that circulates; fair and open financial practices; justice for each person and for society.
- Framework · meansHow should finance work?
Make financial contracts possible; set values and standards; build in social responsibility.
- Our questions · resultsWhat actually happened?
Did people understand the costs? Could they manage the payments? Who benefited, and who was left out? Ask for evidence, not a slogan.
Text description of this figure
Read the figure as three levels, not as a promise. The framework names three ends: wealth circulation, fair and open practices, and justice. It names three means: contracts, values and standards, and social responsibility. To claim the aims were achieved, you need data about results. A signed contract or a mission statement cannot show that on its own.
The idea has a longer history than a feel-good slogan. In a 2013 article in TAFHIM, the same authors discuss the classical list of five essentials that Shariah protects: faith, life, intellect, lineage (family) and property. They also discuss three levels of priority: essentials (daruriyyat), needs that make life easier (hajiyyat) and refinements (tahsiniyyat). They say this classification comes from the scholar al-Ghazali and was developed by later scholars.3 We report this through the authors. We have not checked the medieval texts ourselves. These five categories are not five boxes a product ticks to be approved. They also do not promise that an investment will keep your money safe.
In another 2013 paper, the authors argue that Islamic finance must do two things. It must follow the legal rules. It must also help build a wider financial system that works for people. That paper is The Foundations of Islamic Finance and The Maqasid al-Shari’ah Requirements, in the Journal of Islamic Finance 2(1), pages 31–37.2 Its reference list names their 2012 ISRA Research Paper 32, The objective of the Shariah in Islamic finance: Identifying the ends (maqasid) and the means (wasa’il). We could not get the full text of that paper, so we do not say what it found.2
The objectives in everyday life
Here is one everyday Malaysian example for each objective. The examples are ours, not the authors’. They show what each aim can look like in daily money matters. They are not a test that a product passes or fails.
| Objective | In plain words | Everyday Malaysian example |
|---|---|---|
| Wealth circulation | Money should move into useful activity, not just sit or pile up with a few people. | Savings placed with a bank help fund a nasi lemak seller in Johor Bahru to buy a second stall. |
| Fair and open practices | People should see the real terms and costs before they sign. | A clerk in Kuching gets the Product Disclosure Sheet (PDS) showing the total she will pay, not just the monthly instalment. |
| Justice for people and society | No side should be treated unfairly, and the weak should not be pushed aside. | An e-hailing driver in Penang who loses income is told who to contact and what options exist, instead of only getting demand letters. |
| Essential | What it protects | Everyday Malaysian example |
|---|---|---|
| Faith (din) | Your religious life and values | A teacher in Ipoh saves for umrah in an account that avoids interest (riba). |
| Life (nafs) | Health and safety | A family in Kuantan has medical takaful, so a hospital bill does not delay treatment. |
| Intellect (‘aql) | Clear thinking and knowledge | Before signing, a factory worker in Shah Alam has the costs explained in plain words, so he can decide for himself. |
| Lineage, family (nasl) | Family and the next generation | A father in Kota Bharu names his children as nominees on his family takaful certificate. |
| Property, wealth (mal) | Your money and belongings | A retiree in Melaka checks that a company is licensed before investing, and walks away from a “guaranteed 10% a month” offer. |
All names and places are made up. One product can touch several objectives at once. A product name or advert that mentions these aims does not prove it meets them.

What it means for a household decision
Imagine a Malaysian family who needs to replace an essential appliance, such as a broken washing machine, and is thinking of taking financing. A useful purchase is the benefit they hope for. But the family still needs to know:
- what the contract is;
- how much cash they will receive;
- the full cost; and
- how much room is left in the monthly budget.
Buying something useful with payments that do not suit you can cause strain. Buying a cheaper item, saving first or waiting are options to compare. They are not rules that every family must follow.
One financing decision, looked at three ways
- ContractWhat creates the debt?
Check the documents for the real sales, who owns what, who acts as agent, and how you repay. A good use for the money does not prove the deal was done properly.
- UnderstandingCan you explain the cost?
Write down the cash you receive, each instalment, the total you pay, extra fees, any rebate and what happens if you miss payments. An instalment that looks affordable is only part of the picture.
- BudgetWhat is left each month?
In this example, RM300 is left after the new payment. That is just a sum. It does not show that the financing makes the family better off, or that it suits them.
Text description of this figure
Take-home income is RM4,000. Essentials cost RM2,600 and existing payments are RM500, so RM900 is left before the new instalment. After a RM600 instalment, RM300 is left. If income drops by RM400 to RM3,600 and spending stays the same, the family is RM100 short each month. The sum leaves out several things. These are savings goals, bills that do not come every month, taxes or fees not already in essentials, financing fees, takaful, changes in spending and emergencies. It does not decide whether RM300 is enough.
The full sum is in the text description above. The lesson is not that RM300 is always a safe amount to have left. Every household has different needs and different savings to fall back on. The example also gives no financing amount, period or fees. So it cannot show the total cost of the financing or its effective rate. Check those separately. Do not treat the RM600 payment as an affordable quote.
Ask the provider what happens if your situation changes, such as losing income or falling ill:
- Who should you contact?
- What documents will you need?
- What options are there, and what do they cost?
Do not assume you will get a restructured plan or that fees will be waived. Get the explanations in writing, so the family can compare them with the actual contract terms.
A good aim still needs the right process and rules
Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) has a policy called Fair Treatment of Financial Consumers. It covers named types of financial providers, including licensed Islamic banks. It has two kinds of rules: standards marked S, which providers must follow, and guidance marked G, which is advice. Fair terms, clear information and fair treatment of vulnerable customers are required, not just marketing themes.4
BNM issued the policy on 27 March 2024, and most of it took effect that day. Some parts listed in paragraph 4.1 took effect later, on 1 April 2025. These include the rules on vulnerable customers in paragraphs 16.1–16.28. These dates tell you when the rules began. They do not tell you how any bank actually behaves.4
BNM’s Shariah Governance policy sets out who inside an Islamic bank is responsible for following Shariah. BNM issued it on 20 September 2019. Most of it took effect on 1 April 2020, and paragraph 12.5 on 1 April 2023.5
The rules work in both directions:
- A customer cannot skip a contract requirement by saying the purchase helps the family.
- A product structure, or a Shariah committee’s process, does not by itself show that the family understood the terms or ended up better off.

A hope is not the same as a result
When someone says a product “does good”, ask what kind of claim it is. Each kind needs different evidence.
What evidence supports the claim?
A claim about what should happen.
Author, original work, year and what it covers. It does not show that every product meets the aim.
A rule from a regulator is different from a promise a provider makes in its contract.
Check who issued it, whether it is marked S or G, who it applies to, when it took effect and the actual contract. Records are needed to show it was followed.
A claim about what did happen. It needs a clear meaning of “better off”.
Which customers, over what period, after which costs? Compare with other options and other causes before saying the finance made the difference.
Text description of this figure
A research paper supports an aim, credited to its authors. A required policy paragraph supports a rule, but only within its scope and from its start date. A contract supports the promises in it; records are needed to show they were carried out. A claim that things improved needs clear measures, a defined group of people and a time period. To show the finance caused the improvement, you also need to rule out other options and other influences. This guide does not claim any measured improvement in welfare.
On 22 March 2018, BNM announced its final strategy on Value-based Intermediation (VBI). VBI aims for Islamic finance to create positive, lasting value for the economy, the community and the environment. Each bank was to adopt it at its own pace, depending on how ready it was.6 This is useful Malaysian background on turning aims into practice. But the announcement does not prove that every bank adopted every part, or that any one family became better off.
Suppose a report says more people received financing. Ask what that measures. Is it access to finance, stress from repayments, or real overall benefit? These are different results. Check:
- the time period and which people were counted;
- how terms were defined;
- fees and missed payments; and
- who was left out.
A before-and-after change can also come from other things, such as income, inflation or other help. A strong claim that financing caused an improvement needs a fair comparison and a sound method. We do not make up a maqasid score. And the made-up budget above is not research on results.
Good intentions do not remove costs
A good intention does not cancel what you owe. For any offer, check:
- the total amount payable;
- stamp duty, and duty on security documents;
- charges for late or missed payments;
- costs of any security (collateral);
- takaful costs;
- agency terms (where the bank buys or sells for you); and
- any rebate (ibra’).
Get the documents that apply to your own offer. None of these costs is in the made-up budget above.
Example from a real document: HSBC Amanah
HSBC Amanah’s Product Disclosure Sheet (PDS), dated September 2026, says stamp duty of 0.5% of the financing amount applies only when collateral is required. There may also be separate duty on security documents. It also mentions a late-payment charge worked out daily.7 The March 2026 terms separately describe the agency, the selling price, the rebate and later stages of late-payment charges.8 Read each document according to its date and title.
In that HSBC Amanah deal, you first buy a commodity from the bank. The cash then comes from selling that commodity on. You still have to pay the bank its selling price.8,7 Do not assume your appliance is the commodity being traded.
Wanting to help your family does not remove:
- the repayments;
- the chance that the bank takes action to collect money you owe; or
- the need to check any optional protection and what it does not cover.
If takaful is offered with the financing, ask whether it is optional or required. Read the actual takaful certificate for what it covers, what it excludes and what it costs. We do not assume you have any cover.
Who can use these questions?
Any Malaysian, Muslim or not, can ask about fairness, clear costs and evidence of benefit. For the HSBC Amanah financing used here, its FAQ says the product is open to eligible Muslims and non-Muslims.9 That does not mean everyone qualifies, or that you personally will be approved.
Religious concerns stay important for Muslim readers. A non-Muslim reader can compare the same cash, payments and service without taking on a religious identity. Words about welfare do not settle who can join every social-finance scheme; each scheme has its own conditions.
A short checklist for “this product does good”
- Name the aim. Is it clear pricing, a household that copes better with shocks, access to finance, fair treatment or a wider social result?
- Name the type of evidence. Is it a research argument, a rule providers must follow, a promise in the contract, a record that the deal was carried out, or a measured result?
- Ask who gains and who pays. Who benefits, who pays, who bears a loss and who may be left out? Include the full period and all fees when you compare costs.
- Test your own budget. Allow for bills that do not come every month and for changes that could happen. A bank’s approval does not replace your family’s own understanding.
- Get it in writing. If the terms or the way you are treated are unclear, ask for a written explanation and use the provider’s complaints process. Our complaints guide explains where to go next.
A claim that a product “does good” is useful when it tells you three things: what is promised, what evidence there is and what is still uncertain.
If payments become hard
- Struggling to keep up with financing payments? AKPK, the credit counselling agency set up by BNM, gives free advice and can help you plan repayments.
- A dispute with your bank or takaful operator? Use its complaints process first. If you are still unhappy, the Financial Markets Ombudsman Service (FMOS) is free for you, but it has limits and deadlines.
- Offered a “Shariah” scheme with a fixed, high return and “no risk”? That is a common scam sign. If you have already sent money, call the National Scam Response Centre at 997 straight away.
References
This is a new plain-language explanation, not an original ISRA research finding or an endorsement of any provider. We reopened the original sources on 6 October 2026. The dates printed below are the documents’ own dates. The older research explains ideas; public documents do not prove how a deal was carried out or what happened for any customer. The PDFs stay on their publishers’ websites.
- Developing Islamic finance in the framework of maqasid al-Shari'ah: Understanding the ends (maqasid) and the means (wasa'il) — Mohamad Akram Laldin and Hafas FurqaniEmerald Publishing · 2013; International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management 6(4), pp.278–289; DOI 10.1108/IMEFM-05-2013-0057Publisher abstract: purpose, method, findings, limitations; author informationPublic abstract and metadata recovered; full text access restricted. Only stated ends/means and conceptual scope used. Historical ISRA affiliation, not current posts.
- The Foundations of Islamic Finance and The Maqasid al-Shari'ah Requirements — Mohamad Akram Laldin and Hafas FurqaniIIUM Institute of Islamic Banking and Finance, Journal of Islamic Finance · Printed 2013, 2(1), pp.31–37; search crawl/upload date does not change publication yearpp.31,34–36 (§4),37 referencesOriginal conceptual paper fully inspected for selected sections; bibliography proves cited work identity, not unavailable work findings.
- The Future of Islamic Finance: A Reflection Based on Maqasid al-Shari'ah — Mohamad Akram Laldin and Hafas FurqaniIKIM Press, TAFHIM · Printed TAFHIM 6 (2013), pp.41–54pp.47–50: hierarchy, essentials and financial objectivesHistorical classical classification as discussed by the authors; not direct verification of medieval editions or modern measured impacts.
- Fair Treatment of Financial ConsumersBank Negara Malaysia · Issued 27 March 2024; generally effective that date; §4.1 specified provisions effective 1 April 2025§§2–5,8,11–12,15–16; 4.1 deferred listDistinguish S standards from G guidance; applies to specified providers/financial consumers. Later public policy cross-references must be consulted for complaints procedure.
- Shariah Governance policy documentBank Negara Malaysia · Issued 20 September 2019; effective 1 April 2020 except §12.5 effective 1 April 2023§§1–5; 8.1; governance roles; §§4.1–4.2 effective datesRequirements and governance process; not a certificate for the examples or evidence of customer outcomes.
- Finalised Strategy Paper on Value-based Intermediation: Strengthening the Roles and Impact of Islamic FinanceBank Negara Malaysia · Release 22 March 2018; follows consultation paper 20 July 2017Announcement: aim and adoption based on each institution's readinessStrategy aspirations, not a measured welfare finding or a blanket binding product rule. Printed strategy-paper date not asserted from announcement.
- Personal Financing Product Disclosure SheetHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Sep2026; customer date blank; effective date not separately statedpp.1–2: concept, obligations, charges, risksPublic illustration, not a quotation; collateral stamp-duty condition retained; late-payment summary not all stages.
- Personal Financing-i Terms and ConditionsHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Mar26; effective date not separately stated§§4–5,7,9–10,12–14Agency/selling-price/rebate description; other-stage late-payment base differs; actual approval advice and execution unavailable.
- Personal Financing-i FAQHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Undated live FAQIs this personal financing for Muslim customers only?; processing feeEligible Muslims and non-Muslims; no personal approval or universal eligibility. Public thresholds differ from landing page and are omitted.
- Lembaran Pendedahan Produk — Pembiayaan Peribadi HSBC AmanahHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Sep2026; customer date blank; effective date not separately statedpp.1–2: concept, obligations, charges, risksPublic illustration, not a quotation; collateral stamp-duty condition retained; late-payment summary not all stages.
- Terma dan Syarat Pembiayaan Peribadi-iHSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad · Printed v.Mac 26 (Malay original, March 2026); effective date not separately stated§§4–5,7,9–10,12–14Agency/selling-price/rebate description; other-stage late-payment base differs; actual approval advice and execution unavailable.
