Skip to content

Research

Independent reconstruction of Paper 17/2010: Islamic pricing benchmark

Only public abstracts were recovered; this page cannot explain or evaluate the proposed formula or results. It can show the research question and the process described in those abstracts. For a financing decision today, compare the rate named in your offer, the contract and the total payment obligation separately.

Sources checked 6 October 2026

Original resource: Islamic Pricing Benchmarking / An Islamic Pricing Benchmark

Educational explanation · evidence checked within stated source limits

ISRA.my historical guide. This page explains an historical ISRA research-paper record and links the original institutional records separately as sources. It does not constitute institutional Shariah or legal approval.

Identity sources: [D10] [C10] [I3] [I7] [D16]

Hands hold an open book with pink and green sticky notes.
Illustrative image only; the book shown is not the publication discussed.

What the public abstract says about the research process

The public records describe a Malaysian project that sought an Islamic benchmark for the cost of capital. They say the team reviewed Shariah perspectives and conventional benchmarks, developed a theoretical model and tested it through simulation. The recovered abstracts do not disclose the complete formula, dataset, numerical results or final recommendations, so this page does not reconstruct or endorse them. [C10] [I3] [I7]

The verified research process

  1. Question: an alternative Islamic benchmark for Malaysia’s cost of capital
  2. Review: Shariah perspectives + conventional pricing benchmarks
  3. Formulation: theoretical benchmark model
  4. Test: simulation using sectoral and macroeconomic data

Only the process stated in the publisher/repository abstract is mapped. The formula, simulation outcomes and final recommendations are not recovered. This is not a reconstruction of unseen chapters. [C10] [I3] [I7]

Diagram in words

The project aims to develop a Malaysian benchmark, reviews Shariah and conventional benchmarks, formulates a theoretical model and tests it by simulation. Public abstracts do not establish numerical results or adoption.

The available records list contributors differently, and the printed author order was not recovered.

Contributor lists in the available records
  • IIUM 16770: Ahamed Kameel Mydin Meera, Mohd Azmi Omar and Azman Mohd Noor.
  • IIUM 28934: Mohd Azmi Omar, Azman Mohd Noor, Ahamed Kameel Mydin Meera, Turkhan Ali Abdul Manap, M. Shabri Abdul Majid, Sharifah Raihan Syed Mohd Zain and Md Ali Sarif.
  • Archived publisher catalogue: the first three names and a research team.

Repository deposit dates in 2012 and 2013 are not the original publication date. [C10] [I3] [I7] [AM]

Bundles of papers are stacked on metal shelves.
Illustrative image only; the papers shown are not the historical records discussed.

Publication details and conflicting citations

The address is not a stable paper identifier

  1. 4 October 2010 capture → /224.html identifies 17/2010
  2. 18 October + 7 November 2010 referrers → benchmarking context; November cites 17/2010
  3. 6 December 2013 catalogue capture → Paper 17 still links /224.html
  4. 9 November 2016 capture → different HTML title: 49/2013; detailed body unavailable
  5. Citation check → match the title, paper number and year; the address alone is insufficient

Capture dates, article dates and paper years have different meanings. The later title does not prove the path changed in 2013 or establish which destination every later link intended. [D10] [ZB] [BG] [C10] [D16]

Diagram in words

The 2010 archive and referring links identify Paper 17. A December 2013 catalogue still points it to the same path. A November 2016 capture has a Paper 49/2013 title without detailed body. The address alone cannot identify the paper; the later work’s full identity and the change date remain unverified.

Provenance: why the numeric address is uncertain

An October 2010 download identifies Paper 17/2010. Zaharuddin’s 18 October 2010 article and Blake Goud’s 7 November 2010 post link or cite it. A December 2013 catalogue capture still links Paper 17 to the address, while a November 2016 capture gives the address the HTML title “Research Paper (No.49/2013)” without exposing a detailed body. This proves a conflict, not a replacement date. [D10] [ZB] [BG] [C10] [D16]

This numeric URL was later reused; cite the work by its title, paper number and year. The available captures do not establish the full identity of Paper 49/2013 or the date on which the address changed.

What a benchmark does in Malaysia today

Start with the rate name in your own offer. For a covered floating-rate facility, compare that reference rate and the bank’s added spread; together they affect the financing rate. Not every facility is floating.

NameWhere it may appearWhat to do
Standardised Base Rate (SBR)Covered new retail applications received from 1 August 2022, including specified refinancing and revolving renewalsCheck the current SBR, the spread and when instalments may change.
Overnight Policy Rate (OPR)BNM policy rate followed by SBRDo not mistake it for your final financing rate.
Base Rate (BR), Base Lending Rate (BLR) or Base Financing Rate (BFR)Older facilities that have not been refinanced or renewed as specifiedUse the exact older rate named in the agreement.

[RRF]

Research note: MYOR-i

MYOR-i is an overnight interbank benchmark based on eligible Shariah-compliant placements under BNM’s 25 March 2022 document. It is not the household contract rate in the example, does not prove that the 2010 proposal was adopted and does not automatically replace the rate in a customer’s agreement. [MY]

Three checks before comparing a price

  1. Reference rate + spread → rate: fictional 3.00% + 1.20 percentage points = 4.20%
  2. Same spread, reference +0.25 points → 3.25% + 1.20 points = 4.45%
  3. Contract → ownership, security, payment terms and rebate
  4. Actual cost depends on: balance, tenure, rate path, payment schedule, fees and protection costs

Fictional arithmetic shows the reference-rate/spread relationship in BNM §9.4, not the 2010 research formula or a bank quote. Spread is held constant. No monthly instalment, all-in annual rate, future rate path or total payable is calculated. Read the actual contract and dated offer. [RRF] [MH]

Diagram in words

Fictional rate 3.00% plus spread 1.20 percentage points equals 4.20%. If the reference increases 0.25 percentage points with spread unchanged, the rate is 4.45%. The contract separately determines ownership and obligations. Total cost needs the actual balance, tenure, schedule, rate path and additional costs.

Hands hold a calculator and write in a notebook beside a laptop and yellow folder.
Illustrative image only; it does not establish product terms, eligibility or outcomes.

The contract and the actual bill are separate

The examined Maybank Islamic CM Home Financing-i disclosure describes commodity purchase by the bank, a marked-up deferred sale to the customer, and an agency resale for cash disbursed under facility terms. The property secures the financing. It distinguishes effective and ceiling rates and warns that instalments may rise. Its customer date is blank and no issue/version date is printed, so we use it as a public product-document example, not a dated current offer. Its listed advance-redraw/letter fees and late charges need checking alongside legal, valuation and protection costs in your actual quotation. It requires fire takaful/insurance for residential premises pledged as collateral; cover for the financing balance upon death or permanent disability is separately encouraged. [MH]

A fixed-rate facility does not change merely because an economy-wide benchmark moves. The benchmark also does not tell you whether two contracts have the same ownership, rebate, default or Shariah terms. For worked product examples, read Profit versus interest: what should borrowers compare?

A useful comparison checklist

  • Find the actual reference-rate name and spread. Compare effective rates on the same balance and tenure, not just headline flat rates or SBR alone.
  • Ask which contract governs ownership and payment; distinguish the commodity transaction from property security and from the benchmark formula.
  • Obtain the dated disclosure and offer: amount disbursed, full instalment schedule, conditional fees, ceiling, rebate, late/default terms and protection costs.
  • Ask what happens if the reference rate rises or falls and when the instalment changes. A displayed monthly payment remaining unchanged does not prove total cost is unchanged.
  • For historical citations, record the title, paper number, issuer and publication year as well as the URL. Keep a capture date and a repository deposit date in separate fields.

[RRF] [MH] [HP] [C10] [I3] [I7]

Related reading

The links below lead to related guides and source records on this site.

References

Accessed: 6 October 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur). Publication years, capture dates and repository deposit dates are distinct. Original titles are retained; BM is an authored explanation, not an issuer-certified translation.

  1. [D10] Download summary — Islamic Pricing Benchmarking (17/2010) — ISRA

    Archive capture: 2010-10-04 01:26:10 UTC · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Summary: title and paper number

  2. [C10] Research Paper 2010 catalogue — Paper 17 entry — ISRA

    Publication: 2010 (year only) · Archive capture: 2013-12-06 19:15:55 UTC · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Paper 17/2010: title, credit, 78 pages and abstract; link to /summary/29/224.html

  3. [I3] An Islamic pricing benchmark — International Islamic University Malaysia Repository

    Publication: 2010 (work year) · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Citation, abstract, Additional Information, repository access status

  4. [I7] Islamic pricing benchmarking — International Islamic University Malaysia Repository

    Publication: 2010 (work year) · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Citation, seven authors, abstract, access status

  5. [AM] Islamic pricing benchmarking — author publication entry — Ahamed Kameel Mydin Meera website

    Publication: 2010 (work year) · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Title; author list; issue 17; abstract; repository link

  6. [IP] IRP 17 — Islamic Pricing Benchmark — I-FIKR

    Publication: 2010 (work year) · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Indexed 2010 abstract and truncated author display

  7. [ZB] Perbankan Islam dan BFR — Zaharuddin Abd Rahman

    Publication: 2010-10-18 · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Closing further-reading link to http://isra.my/media-centre/downloads/summary/29/224.html

  8. [BG] An Islamic pricing benchmark? — Blake Goud / Sharing Risk

    Publication: 2010-11-07 · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Date, footnote 1 and linked title to www /summary/29/224.html

  9. [D16] Reused numeric path — title Research Paper (No.49/2013) — Archived ISRA page

    Archive capture: 2016-11-09 19:35:56 UTC · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: HTML title and hidden main-content context

  10. [RRF] Reference Rate Framework — Bank Negara Malaysia

    Publication: 2026-03-27 · Effective: 2026-07-01 · Printed version: BNM/RH/PD 028-23 · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: §§4.1, 5.2, 7.1, 9.1–9.5, 9.10; §§9.13–9.22

  11. [MY] Malaysia Islamic Overnight Rate (MYOR-i) — Bank Negara Malaysia

    Publication: 2022-03-25 · Effective: 2022-03-25 · Printed version: BNM/RH/PD 034-4 · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: §§4.1, 7.1; Appendix2

  12. [MH] Commodity Murabahah Home Financing-i PDS — Maybank Islamic Berhad

    Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: pp.1–2; contract, obligations, fees, risks, protection; p.2 §4: mandatory fire cover for pledged residential premises; separately encouraged death/permanent-disability balance cover

  13. [HP] HSBC Amanah Personal Financing — Product Disclosure Sheet — HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad

    Printed version: v.Sep2026 · Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: pp. 1–2; What is; obligations; risks

  14. [HF] Personal Financing-i FAQ — HSBC Amanah Malaysia Berhad

    Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: Muslim customers only?; What is APF-i?

  15. [REG] Banking & Islamic Banking policy register — Bank Negara Malaysia

    Accessed: 6 October 2026
    Locator: 28 December 2018 Tawarruq; 27 March 2026 Reference Rate Framework

Independent editorial source record. This is not an official ISRA publication or an institutional Shariah/legal approval.

Related reading

Search ISRA.my

Search guides, glossary terms, research records and publications.