Practical guide

Staking, DeFi and crypto yield: where does the return come from?

Every crypto “yield” is paid by someone: the network, a borrower, a trader or a reward programme. Ask who pays, and what you must do or risk to get it. A high or “guaranteed” yield means high risk, and it is a common sign of a scam. Validation rewards, loan interest, trading fees and incentive tokens are different sources. One token can be used in many different arrangements. A coin’s Shariah status does not approve every way it is used.

A hand holds a phone with a blank white screen above a table indoors.

Words used on this page:

  • Yield: the return a product says you will earn, often shown as a percentage a year.
  • Staking: locking up coins to help a blockchain network run, in return for rewards. Networks that work this way use “proof of stake”.
  • Validator: a participant who runs software that checks and confirms transactions on the network.
  • Slashing: a penalty that destroys part of the staked coins when a validator breaks the rules.
  • DeFi (decentralised finance): financial services run by smart contracts.
  • Smart contract: a program on a blockchain that runs by itself when its conditions are met.
  • Collateral: assets you lock up to back a loan.
  • Liquidation: a forced sale of your collateral when your loan becomes too risky.
  • Liquidity pool: a shared pot of tokens that traders swap against. People who add tokens to it earn part of the trading fees.
  • Lock-up: a period when you cannot take your coins out.

Four sources of return to keep apart

“Earn” is a marketing label. DeFi means decentralised finance: financial services that usually run through smart contracts. Neither label tells you what the contract is. When you see a percentage, find out four things first:

  • who pays it;
  • which token the reward is paid in;
  • what the fee is charged on; and
  • when and how you can get out.

Until you know these, the number does not tell you much.

1. Staking (validation rewards)

In proof-of-stake staking, you put your tokens at risk while a validator helps the network confirm transactions. The rewards pay for that work. But poor performance or cheating can cut the rewards, or cost part of the stake.

On Ethereum, staked ETH gives validators a money reason to follow the network’s rules. Their work includes proposing new blocks, checking them and confirming them (“attestations”). A validator that goes offline earns less. One that clearly cheats can be “slashed”, which destroys part of its stake.1

You can stake directly, hand the work to an operator, join a pool, or stake through a provider that holds your coins (custodial staking). Each way brings different operators and custody risks. These Ethereum details are not the same on every blockchain.1

2. Lending (borrower interest)

Lending works differently. Aave describes supplying tokens to a lending pool. Borrowers take loans from the pool, backed by collateral. The interest you earn and what borrowers owe follow the protocol’s settings (parameters).2

3. Liquidity provision (trading fees)

Here you add tokens to a pool that traders swap against. Uniswap’s documents say trading fees go to the liquidity that is active at the time. Protocol fees are separate, and the rules differ between versions.6

4. Incentive tokens (reward programmes)

Some platforms hand out extra reward tokens under a set programme. Aave V3 documents a reward rate and an end date for such programmes. The payout itself is not proof that the money comes from borrower interest, trading fees or newly created tokens.8

Figure 1. Where does the advertised return come from?

Four different reward routes • a comparison, not an instruction or a single product

  • ValidationNetwork rewards and some transaction fees → validator or staking operator → you, under the arrangement. Risks: penalties for poor performance, and operator or custody risk.
  • LendingBorrower pays interest → pool, under its rate rules → supplier. The borrower owes a debt. The supplier is exposed to the pool, its contracts and when withdrawals are possible.
  • Liquidity provisionTrader pays a swap fee → split under the pool’s rules → active liquidity provider. Your mix of tokens can change. Its value can end up lower than if you had just held them.
  • Incentive tokensA set reward-token programme → people who qualify. This is separate from interest or trading fees. Check who funds it, what the token is worth and when it ends.
How the four routes work, based on Ethereum staking, Aave supply and V3 incentive documents, and Uniswap fee documents. A product may combine routes, but check each one separately. We assume no live rate, active campaign, shared contract or Malaysian approval. Explanation written by ISRA.my.12867
Hands type on a black keyboard beside an unlit phone and a coffee cup.

What leaves your control, and what comes back?

Follow two things: where your tokens go, and what you now owe or are owed.

Custodial staking

A provider may hold your tokens and arrange the staking with another operator. Luno’s terms say the tokens stay yours in economic terms. But Luno holds and records them, possibly in blockchain addresses shared with other customers.911 That wording alone does not tell you how fast, or how fully, you would get them back if the provider went bust (insolvency). Ask how your tokens are recorded and kept separate. Ask how they are returned if the service or the provider fails.

Lending pools

If you supply tokens to a lending pool, you depend on the pool’s contracts. You also depend on how much is free to withdraw, and on the borrowing behind it. Aave says you can only withdraw what has not been borrowed. If you use your supplied tokens as collateral, your loan adds more limits.5 Supplier and borrower are different roles. Supplying tokens on its own is not the same as taking a leveraged loan.

Liquidity pools

As people trade, the mix of tokens you hold in the pool changes. For example, if one token’s price rises elsewhere, traders buy it cheaply from the pool. You end up with less of the token that went up.

Uniswap v2’s guide separates fee earnings from losses compared with simply holding.7 So compare your final value with what you would have had if you had just kept the original tokens. The fees may not cover the gap, even if both choices made money in ringgit. This shortfall is often called “impermanent loss”.

In Uniswap v3 and v4 (“concentrated liquidity”), you choose a price range for your position. It earns swap fees only while the market price is inside that range. When the price moves outside, it stops earning until the price comes back.6 Do not copy a v2 calculation onto every v3 or v4 position.

Liquid staking

Some services give you a receipt token for your staked coins. This adds another layer: a claim, and a token with its own price. Selling the receipt is different from withdrawing the original staked coins. Using the receipt as collateral adds a loan on top. Read the redemption, custody and loss terms for every layer. The word “liquid” does not promise that you can cash out at once at full value.1

Borrowing adds a debt and a forced-sale risk

Leverage means using borrowed money or tokens to make your bet bigger. A strategy that borrows has a cost, the interest, as well as a reward. Aave says interest starts adding up as soon as you borrow, and rates can change.3

To borrow, you lock up collateral. Your collateral’s value may fall, or your debt may grow. If either goes too far, the collateral can be taken. This is called liquidation. Another user, called a liquidator, repays part of your debt. In return, they receive some of your collateral plus a bonus, under the protocol’s rules.4 This can happen without waiting for you.

Think of a loan backed by gold. If the price of gold falls far enough, the lender can sell the gold to clear the loan. In DeFi, a program does this automatically, at any hour.

Aave tracks this risk with a number called the health factor. Below 1, the loan can be liquidated. Exactly 1 is the edge.4

Worked example: the health factor

Figure 2 uses only Aave’s health-factor formula. All values are made up and shown in ringgit terms. There is one type of collateral, a fixed debt of RM6,000 and an assumed liquidation threshold of 80%. This does not mean Aave lends ringgit. It also does not mean 80% applies in any market today.4

In this example, the formula is:

Health factor = collateral value × 0.80 ÷ RM6,000 debt

  • RM10,000 collateral: 10,000 × 0.80 = 8,000. Then 8,000 ÷ 6,000 = 1.333.
  • RM7,500 collateral: 7,500 × 0.80 = 6,000. Then 6,000 ÷ 6,000 = exactly 1.

Below RM7,500, this simple model can be liquidated. Sitting exactly at 1 is the edge, not a safe level.

The debt can move the edge too, even if prices do not fall. If the debt grows to RM6,500, the edge rises to RM8,125 of collateral (6,500 ÷ 0.80).

Do not mix up two different limits: the starting borrowing limit (loan-to-value) and the liquidation threshold. The chart is not a borrowing limit. It also leaves out real price feeds, loans with several collateral or debt tokens, and rule changes by the protocol’s governance. Liquidation amounts, bonuses and transaction costs are left out too.43

Figure 2. Leverage and liquidation

Made-up model with one collateral • values in RM terms • fixed debt RM6,000 • assumed threshold 80%

Health factor (HF) = collateral value × 0.80 ÷ RM6,000 debt. The bars show collateral value, not the chance of a loss.

  • RM10,000HF 1.333 · Above the edge, but not a safety guarantee
  • RM8,500HF 1.133 · Above the edge, but not a safety guarantee
  • RM7,500HF 1.000 · Exactly at the edge
  • RM7,000HF 0.933 · Below 1: can be liquidated in this model

If the debt is RM6,500 instead, HF = 1 needs collateral of RM8,125 (6,500 ÷ 0.80).

Uses Aave’s live formula. All amounts and the 80% threshold are made up. Check the real protocol and market settings and price feeds. The model uses exact values to decide below, at or above 1; labels are rounded to three decimals. It does not work out the liquidation amount, bonus, starting borrowing limit, fees or what you should do.43
Hands press a calculator above an open notebook on a wooden desk.

More tokens can still mean less ringgit

Look at three things separately: the reward before fees, the fees and the value of the coin.

Luno calls its rate the Annual Rewards Percentage (ARP). Luno says the ARP is a yearly estimate based on the last 30 days of staking rewards. It changes with network conditions, and Luno’s service fee is already taken off.18 A recent average is not a promise that the same rate will last a year.

For any offer, ask:

  • how the percentage is worked out;
  • whether it assumes you reinvest your rewards; and
  • whether you are paid in the same coin or in another token.

A real fee example

Luno’s Malaysia fee page lists the fees below. They are charged on the rewards from the blockchain, not on your whole staked holding.10

CoinLuno’s fee on staking rewards
ADA (Cardano)20%
ETH (Ethereum)30%
SOL (Solana)35%

The page says the estimated ARP already takes this fee into account. Staking and unstaking have no fee of their own. Buying, selling or sending coins can cost extra. Do not take the same reward fee off a net estimate twice.10

Aina’s example

Aina is a made-up investor. She starts with 100 units of a coin worth RM10 each, so RM1,000. Over an assumed period she earns 6 units before fees. A 35% fee on the reward takes 2.1 units, which leaves 3.9 units. She now has 103.9 units.

Then the price falls to RM8 a unit. Her 103.9 units are now worth RM831.20. She has more tokens, but her holding is worth RM168.80 less than at the start.

The 6% reward and the prices are invented. Only the 35% fee basis follows the SOL row on Luno Malaysia’s undated fee page. This is not a forecast of real SOL returns. It leaves out compounding, slashing, tax, and fees for buying, selling or sending.10

Figure 3. A positive token reward, a lower ringgit value

Aina’s made-up figures • 100 units • 6% before fees over an assumed period • 35% fee on the reward • price RM10 → RM8

  1. Starting holding100 units × RM10 = RM1,000.00.
  2. Reward minus fee6.0 units before fees − 2.1 units fee = 3.9 net units.
  3. Value at the end103.9 units × RM8 = RM831.20. Change from the start: minus RM168.80.
Made-up prices and rewards. The 35% fee follows the SOL row of Luno Malaysia’s undated fee page. No real reward rate or future fee is promised. Compounding, slashing, tax and transaction fees are left out. The end value is a price on screen, not cash you actually received.10

Getting out, and who bears a loss

Luno’s staking terms were last updated on 11 September 2025. They describe possible delays:

  • a lock-in period;
  • a warm-up period before staking starts; and
  • a wait when you unstake.

They also warn that slashing can cost you rewards or part of the coins you staked (your principal).9

The terms limit Luno’s liability. Some slashing losses may be caused by the validator provider’s intentional misconduct, gross negligence or deliberate breach. For those, the terms point to a possible claim against that provider. But they do not set out how a customer would claim. They also do not promise that you will get money back. Luno does not guarantee that the service will always be available. It can also restrict access under the conditions it sets out.9

For any arrangement, ask who bears the loss if:

  • a validator is penalised;
  • hackers exploit a flaw in the code;
  • a price feed gives a wrong price;
  • the custodian fails; or
  • you cannot withdraw.45

The word “decentralised” does not tell you who controls upgrades, or who you can turn to for a remedy. A strategy may combine a receipt token, a loan and a liquidity pool. Then it has several contracts and several ways out. A good assessment of the token cannot remove those extra duties.

Shariah: check the coin, the activity and the exact version

A Shariah approval for a coin is not an approval for every way you use it.

What the SC’s Shariah rules cover

In 2020, the SC’s Shariah Advisory Council (SAC) issued a resolution on digital assets. It covers only assets under the SC’s jurisdiction. It sets conditions on how money raised is used, and on rights and benefits. It is not a blanket approval of overseas protocols, lending or every staking arrangement.12

The SC’s current Islamic capital market guidelines cover digital asset exchanges (DAX). A DAX that wants to offer a Shariah-compliant digital currency must first get the SAC’s endorsement. That rule alone does not certify a separate yield contract.13

Luno’s staking certificates

Luno’s help page says its ETH, SOL and ADA staking services are certified.14 We reopened the three original certificate copies that it links to:

ServiceCertified byDate printedAt our check on 6 October 2026
ETH stakingAmanie Advisors1 November 2024Valid for one year, with a yearly review. The first year has passed. The copy we checked does not show a renewal.15
SOL stakingSharlife9 October 2025Valid for one year, with a yearly review or renewal. One-year mark: 9 October 2026.16
ADA stakingSharlife15 October 2025Valid for one year, with a yearly review or renewal. One-year mark: 15 October 2026.17

The SOL and ADA copies also require the arrangement to stay consistent, and any change to be reviewed. Our check date fell before their one-year mark. But that does not confirm how the service runs today, or that it was renewed later.1617

What to check yourself

Check the exact service, the document version and the current certificate, not just the token name. An assessment of one token or one service does not cover every use of that token. The copies we checked cover only named Luno Malaysia services, not every use of ETH, SOL or ADA. They also do not prove that today’s service is unchanged.151617

The certificates describe different contracts:

  • SOL: investment agency and a profit-sharing partnership.
  • ADA: agency, plus a reward for a service.

The ADA copy says no agency fee (wakalah fee) is charged. But the reward fee that Luno publishes does not show how that fee is shared out under the contract. It also does not prove that today’s terms match the documents that were assessed.1710

Before you decide, check:

  • the certificate date and the named service;
  • the documents that were assessed;
  • any validity, review or renewal condition; and
  • what is still unconfirmed.

Do not read the provider’s general list of contracts as one identical contract for every coin. A certificate image online is proof of what it prints. It is not an audit of how things run today. This page does not give any new Shariah ruling.14

Muslim and non-Muslim readers

For Muslim readers, the key question is this. Do the actual contract, reward source, fees, penalties and duties fall within a valid assessment of that service and version? Non-Muslim readers can use the same checks on where the return comes from and what rights they have.

Religion alone does not decide who can use a provider. Luno’s account terms require, among other things, that you are 18 or older, legally able to make a contract, and verified. Where you live and whether the service is offered there also matter. This guide does not decide anyone’s eligibility.11

Figure 4. What still needs checking?

Four separate checks • passing one does not mean passing the others

  • Coin statusThe SC resolution covers assets under SC jurisdiction, with conditions for each asset. It does not cover every use or overseas platforms.
  • Arrangement and versionThe actual payer, contract, fees, penalty and how you get your coins back. The certificate for the named service, and the documents assessed.
  • Certificate dateETH copy: 1 Nov 2024; its first one-year period has passed. SOL: 9 Oct 2025 → one-year mark 9 Oct 2026. ADA: 15 Oct 2025 → one-year mark 15 Oct 2026. Our check: 6 Oct 2026.
  • How it runs, access and remediesNot confirmed: that the service runs as assessed, or that it was renewed. Check custody, lock-ups, liquidation and who may take part, one by one.
Based on the SC SAC resolution (2020), the current Islamic capital market guidelines (30 March 2026) and the original certificate images published by the provider. Covers named Luno Malaysia services only. SOL and ADA need a yearly review or renewal, must stay consistent, and any change must be reviewed. No new ruling is given, and we do not confirm how the provider runs the service today.1213151617

Checklist for any yield claim

This list helps you understand a claim. It does not pick a platform or recommend that you join. If nobody can explain where the reward comes from and what you owe, a high percentage does not fill that gap.

  • Who pays: the network, a borrower, a trader or an incentive programme? Which token is paid?
  • What is the percentage based on, over what period, and how is it worked out? Is it before or after fees?
  • Do you keep the coin, get a claim on a pool or a receipt token, or take on a debt? Who holds the keys?
  • What charges, penalties, lock-ups and liquidity rules affect getting out?
  • Could interest, price feeds or changed thresholds put your collateral up for liquidation?
  • Which exact certificate, date, renewal and assessed documents cover this arrangement?
  • Is the platform registered with the SC? Is its name on the SC Investor Alert List?
  • Are you being pushed to recruit others, or asked for your seed phrase? If so, stop.

References

Where known, each entry shows when the source was published, when it was revised or took effect, and when we read it. The titles name the original documents. All diagrams and explanations on this page are our own new work. The links go to the original documents on other websites. We do not host any PDF here.

  • Ethereum staking: How does it work? — ethereum.org contributor community. Displayed page update: 12 February 2025; body also refers to later Pectra changes. Accessed 6 October 2026. Used for validation/penalty/method distinctions only, not a live rate or every blockchain. Relevant definitions reread 7 October 2026.
  • Supply Tokens — Aave. Undated live documentation, introduction; accessed 6 October 2026. Describes interest-bearing pool mechanics, not an approved Malaysian offer.
  • Borrow Tokens — Aave. Undated; introduction and rate/accrual explanation; accessed 6 October 2026. No transaction instructions or rate quotation reproduced.
  • Health Factor & Liquidations — Aave. Undated live formula/process page; accessed 6 October 2026. Example uses fictional MYR valuations, fixed debt and assumed 80% threshold; actual liquidation amount/bonus is not modelled.
  • Withdraw Tokens — Aave. Undated; introduction and collateral conditions; accessed 6 October 2026. Availability depends on pool liquidity and borrow exposure.
  • Fees — Uniswap Developers. Undated cross-version documentation; accessed 6 October 2026. Active-liquidity and fee rules; no universal pool fee quoted. Relevant definitions reread 7 October 2026.
  • Understanding Returns (Uniswap v2) — Uniswap Developers. Undated; explicitly Uniswap v2; accessed 6 October 2026. Relative-to-holding risk only; not a model of all concentrated-liquidity positions.
  • Incentives (Aave V3) — Aave. Undated V3 contract documentation; accessed 6 October 2026. Configured reward rates/end dates; no active incentive campaign asserted.
  • Malaysia Staking Terms and Conditions — Luno. Last updated 11 September 2025; §§3–12; accessed 6 October 2026. Provider terms, not a guarantee of recovery or authenticated current execution.
  • Luno fees and limits in Malaysia — Luno. Undated live page; accessed 6 October 2026. Reward-fee basis and net estimated ARP; snapshot, not a promised future charge.
  • Malaysia Terms of use — Luno Malaysia Sdn. Bhd.. Last updated 14 May 2026; §§1/3/4/7; accessed 6 October 2026. Account/custody conditions; no individual eligibility or recovery verified.
  • Digital Assets from Shariah Perspective — Shariah Advisory Council, Securities Commission Malaysia. Meetings 29 June and 20 July 2020; publication/effective date not separately stated. Pages 1–4; accessed 6 October 2026. Limited to SC jurisdiction; not a ruling on every yield arrangement.
  • Guidelines on Islamic Capital Market Products and Services, SC-GL/1-2022 (R2-2026) — Securities Commission Malaysia. Revised/effective 30 March 2026, except a separate annual-declaration provision effective 1 January 2027. Chapters 26 and 38; accessed 6 October 2026. Framework, not proof of a named product’s approval.
  • Is Luno staking Shariah compliant? — Luno. Undated provider statement; accessed 6 October 2026. Linked copies inspected independently; broad wording does not establish current renewal or approval of every activity.
  • Luno Malaysia Ethereum staking — Shariah certificate — Amanie Advisors (provider-published copy). Printed issue date 2024-11-01. Initial one-year period has passed; annual review required. Renewal not established. Accessed 6 October 2026. Named Malaysian staking service only; public copy does not authenticate current implementation.
  • Luno Malaysia Solana staking — Shariah certificate — Sharlife (provider-published copy). Printed issue date 2025-10-09. Review date is within the printed one-year period; anniversary 9 October 2026. Annual review/renewal and unchanged assessed arrangements required. Accessed 6 October 2026. Named Malaysian staking service only; public copy does not authenticate current implementation.
  • Luno Malaysia Cardano staking — Shariah certificate — Sharlife (provider-published copy). Printed issue date 2025-10-15. Review date is within the printed one-year period; anniversary 15 October 2026. Annual review/renewal and unchanged assessed arrangements required. Accessed 6 October 2026. Named Malaysian staking service only; public copy does not authenticate current implementation.
  • How do my staking rewards work? — Luno. Undated live explanation; annual estimate, previous 30-day average and net fee basis; accessed 6 October 2026. No current reward rate or exact waiting time assumed.

Search ISRA.my

Search guides, glossary terms, research records and publications.