Practical guide

Stablecoins, tokenised deposits and CBDCs: what is the difference?

The difference is who owes you the money. A stablecoin is a promise from a private issuer. A tokenised deposit is money a bank owes you. A CBDC is money issued by a central bank. In Malaysia, ringgit stablecoins and tokenised deposits are only being tested between businesses. There is no CBDC for the public.

A hand holds a phone with a dark screen above a payment terminal.

The main difference is who owes you the money. With a stablecoin, your rights depend on the terms set by a private company (the issuer). A tokenised deposit is still money that a commercial bank owes you. A CBDC would be money issued directly by a central bank. For each one, check three things: who must pay you, how you can turn it into ringgit you can spend, and what protection applies.

In legal terms, a stablecoin aims to keep the same value as something else, such as one US dollar, under its issuer’s arrangement. A tokenised bank deposit is a bank’s deposit debt shown as a digital token. A CBDC (central bank digital currency) is a direct debt of the central bank. The three may look alike on a screen. They may use similar blockchain technology. That does not make the claims, cash-out rights, risks or protection the same.

Start with three questions:

  1. Who owes me money?
  2. What supports that promise?
  3. How do I get money that I can spend?

“Tokenised” describes how value is shown and moved. It does not tell you what legal claim or contract sits behind it. Also, keep Malaysia’s dated tests apart from a product offered to the general public.

Words used on this page:

  • Issuer: the company, bank or central bank that creates the token and owes the holder.
  • Liability: what the issuer owes the holder.
  • Backing or reserves: the money or assets that support the issuer’s promise.
  • Redemption: handing the token back to the issuer for the promised currency.
  • Peg: the value a stablecoin aims to keep, such as 1 token = US$1.
  • Retail means for the public. Wholesale means only for banks and other financial firms.
  • Settlement: the step that completes a payment between the parties or their banks.

Three kinds of digital money, three different promises

An issuer’s liability is what it owes the holder. Backing means the resources that support that promise. Redemption is the process of swapping the token for the promised currency or value. Holding a token does not always mean you own a direct share of the reserve assets. It also may not give you a right to ask the issuer for cash with no conditions.1

Stablecoins

A bank, or a private company that is not a bank, may issue a stablecoin. Designs differ. Some hold ordinary currency as reserves; others use other assets. Check the real backing and how the price is kept steady. Don’t guess it from the name. “Stable” is an aim. It is not a promise that the market price stays at the target value.17

Look closely at:

  • the actual issuer;
  • who keeps the reserves (custody);
  • whether the reserves are kept apart from the issuer’s own money (segregation);
  • audits or attestations (an accountant’s report on the reserves);
  • your rights if the issuer goes bust (insolvency); and
  • the conditions for redemption.

Tokenised deposits

Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) has discussed a model for tokenised deposits. In that model, a tokenised deposit is still a claim on the commercial bank that issued it. It is not necessarily a separate pot holding one ringgit of cash for every token. The bank’s balance sheet (everything it owns and owes) and the banking safeguards that apply support the deposit.1 Check the actual contract and who is allowed to hold the token. A token from another company with a bank logo is not proof of a bank deposit.

CBDCs

A CBDC is central-bank money. A retail CBDC is designed for the public. A wholesale CBDC is for financial firms. A CBDC does not have to use a public blockchain.4 The balance in your bank app is normally a claim on your bank, not on the central bank. And a token backed by funds held at a central bank does not automatically give you a direct claim on the central bank.

StablecoinTokenised depositCBDC
Who owes you?A private issuer: a bank or a company that is not a bankThe commercial bank that issued itThe central bank
What do you hold?Rights under the issuer’s terms. Not always a share of the reserves or a right to cash.A bank deposit claim, recorded as a tokenCentral-bank money
What supports it?Reserves, other assets or a price-keeping design. Check each coin.The bank’s balance sheet and banking rules. Not always a separate cash pot.The central bank’s own promise as the issuer of money
Is it legal tender (money that must be accepted to pay a debt)?No. In Malaysia, legal tender is ringgit notes and coins issued by BNM.No. Like a normal bank balance, it is a claim on a bank, not notes and coins.Depends on the law that creates it. Malaysia has no retail CBDC.
PIDM deposit insurance?No. It is not a PIDM-protected deposit. USDC’s terms say it has no deposit insurance.Only if it counts as an eligible deposit at a PIDM member bank. Ask for the protection disclosure.No. Do not treat it as a PIDM-protected deposit.
Can the public use it in Malaysia today?Ringgit stablecoins: only in BNM’s controlled tests between businesses. We have not checked any Malaysian service for foreign coins such as USDC.Only in BNM’s controlled tests (Maybank and CIMB). Not launched for the public.No. The sources we checked show no retail CBDC in Malaysia.

The table sums up the sections on this page. Each row is explained in more detail below.12479

Figure 1

Three kinds of token, three different issuers

Find out who owes you before you compare the technology. The design and the contract decide what you can claim.

Stablecoin

  1. Private issuerA bank or a company that is not a bank. Find out the exact legal company.
  2. Your claimYour rights depend on the actual arrangement and on whether you are an eligible holder.
  3. BackingCheck the reserves, collateral or price-keeping design. Don’t assume you own cash.

Tokenised bank deposit

  1. Commercial bankThe bank owes you the deposit.
  2. Your claimA deposit claim, recorded as a digital token on a programmable platform.
  3. BackingThe bank’s balance sheet and the banking rules that apply. Not automatically a separate cash reserve.

CBDC

  1. Central bankBy definition, the central bank owes it directly.
  2. Your claimCentral-bank money. How people get access depends on the design.
  3. What makes it moneyThe central bank’s own promise as the issuer of money. It does not rest on a private issuer’s promise about reserves.
A simple comparison based on Figure 10 of BNM’s discussion paper and the BIS definition of a CBDC. Stablecoin designs vary. This is not a Malaysian product contract, a deposit-protection certificate or an offer of a retail CBDC.14
Hands write in a squared notebook beside a phone on a white desk.

A price peg is not a way to cash out

Redemption at par means swapping at the stated face value. For example, you hand back one token and get one unit of its reference currency, such as US$1. Selling on an exchange is different. It is a trade with another person or firm at the market price. The two routes can have different access rules, charges and timing. Moving a token alone does not put ringgit into your bank account.7

Circle does not guarantee the price on other platforms. Its terms also say USDC has no deposit insurance.7 For a Malaysian retail holder, the route may look like this: a service sells or converts the token, then pays out to a bank. Each step depends on whether a real provider offers it, and on that provider’s terms. This guide has not checked any Malaysian service that offers USDC.

Reserves behind a coin do not remove these risks:

  • you may not be able to get access;
  • the other party in a deal may fail (counterparty risk);
  • the network may break down; and
  • the exchange rate may move when you convert to ringgit.

For a genuine tokenised bank deposit, ask how the bank turns the token back into an ordinary deposit or an allowed payout. Ask about settlement hours, identity checks and charges.1 For a CBDC, the rules for converting and using it depend on the central bank’s actual design.4 We do not make up fees or redemption rights for a Malaysian retail CBDC.

Figure 2

What must happen before you get your money back?

A legal claim needs a process you can actually use. Keep redeeming with the issuer separate from selling to a middleman.

USDC: straight to the issuer

  1. Eligible Circle Mint customerAn account in good standing. Not offered for retail or personal use.
  2. Ask to redeemThe issuer’s terms, supported networks and compliance checks apply.
  3. Paid in US dollarsFees and bank processing apply. Changing the dollars into ringgit is another step.

Bank deposit token

  1. Authorised depositorThe contract names the holder, the issuing bank and who has access.
  2. Bank converts or pays outThe bank records or pays out what it owes under its terms.
  3. Money you can usePayment systems, opening hours and costs still matter.

CBDC: depends on the design

  1. Eligible user or institutionRetail access and wholesale access are different.
  2. Set conversion channelThe central bank or a service provider, under the scheme’s actual rules.
  3. ResultMoney in a set currency form. A claim on the central bank does not guarantee that every app works without breaks.
USDC is a foreign example, under Circle’s terms for users outside the European Economic Area (EEA). Other stablecoins may differ. The bank and CBDC lanes are concepts, not Malaysian retail offers you can use. No processing time, fee or eligibility is promised.7814

Malaysia: a test is not a launch for the public

BNM’s discussion paper of October 2025 clearly says it does not set final regulatory positions. It talks about possible models and who would be responsible for what. Treat it as an exploration. It is not a new general licence to issue or use tokens.1

On 11 February 2026, BNM announced three controlled wholesale projects. They cover payments within Malaysia and across borders, and settling trades in tokenised assets.3 BNM’s Digital Asset Innovation Hub (DAIH) updated its list of projects on 30 July 2026. The list names:2

  • Standard Chartered Bank Malaysia and Capital A: ringgit stablecoins for settling payments between businesses (B2B);
  • Maybank: payments using tokenised deposits; and
  • CIMB: tokenised deposits used to settle tokenised securities.

A place in the hub is not approval. The hub’s FAQ says admission does not mean or guarantee regulatory recognition. A live launch needs further assessment by BNM.2 The February announcement says BNM intends to give more clarity by the end of 2026. It also says the work may later link up with wholesale CBDC work.3 Neither statement proves that a rule has been issued, that testing is complete or that the public can use it.

The sources we checked do not show any Malaysian retail CBDC that you can use. If someone offers you “digital ringgit”, do not treat it as a CBDC. First look for a current official launch announcement from BNM itself.

Existing laws still apply. The hub’s FAQ says firms must follow the rules on taking deposits, anti-money laundering, foreign exchange and sending money abroad (remittance).2 Separately, the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) regulates digital-asset activities under its capital-market rules.10 Which rules apply depends on the legal type of the product and what is actually being done. A foreign stablecoin issuer’s licence, or a place in the DAIH, is not the same as approval to serve retail users in Malaysia.

Figure 3

An experiment, a product you can use or a rule in force?

Check what kind of document it is, as well as its date. None of these steps shows that the public can use the product.

Check the status

  1. October 2025 · discussionBNM’s exploratory paper. No final regulatory position.
  2. 11 February 2026 · testingControlled wholesale uses announced.
  3. 30 July 2026 · list of projectsThree named projects. This does not mean a retail launch.
  4. By end-2026 · intentionBNM intends to give more policy clarity. Don’t mark this as done.
What the sources said on 6 October 2026; this is not a timeline for finishing. The end-2026 point is BNM’s stated aim, not an issued rule. Joining the DAIH and joining BNM’s Regulatory Sandbox are separate processes.132
Hands use a laptop and hold a phone beside coffee and glasses on a desk.

A token transfer is not always a finished payment

These three checkpoints are different:

  1. a confirmation on a blockchain;
  2. a payment that is final in law; and
  3. money you can spend in a bank account.

The system’s rules and the law decide when a payment debt has been paid off. A “confirmed” message on one blockchain does not by itself prove a final bank payout. Nor does it prove that a tokenised asset was delivered on another system.6

Designs also differ in what the person receiving the money ends up holding. In a bearer-style stablecoin transfer, the receiver can end up holding the same issuer’s token and the rights that come with it.

A non-bearer bank-deposit design works differently. Rodney Garratt and Hyun Song Shin studied one in BIS Bulletin 73. In it, a payment between banks lowers the payer’s deposit. It raises the receiver’s deposit at the receiver’s own bank. The two banks then settle a matching amount in central-bank money. So the receiver keeps a claim on their own bank.5 This is one design model. It does not mean every deposit token or Malaysian pilot works this way.1

Example: Maju pays Sinar RM100

Maju and Sinar are made-up Malaysian companies. They make a RM100 payment in that model:

  • Maju’s deposit at Bank A falls from RM300 to RM200.
  • Sinar’s deposit at Bank B rises from RM40 to RM140.
  • Bank A moves RM100 of central-bank money to Bank B.

The example has no fees, no foreign exchange, no lending (credit) and no retail CBDC balance. If the payment were zero, both balances would stay the same. A payment above RM300 would break the example’s rule that Maju cannot overdraw (no overdraft).

Figure 4

One payment changes two bank claims

A made-up RM100 payment with no fees. Two customer balances change, and the banks settle separately in central-bank money.

Maju → Bank A

  1. BeforeMaju’s deposit claim: RM300.
  2. Payment instructionLower the claim by RM100.
  3. AfterMaju’s deposit claim: RM200.

Bank A → Bank B

  1. Settlement between banksBank A moves RM100 of central-bank money to Bank B.
  2. What the design assumesThe banks have enough money to settle, and every step runs together successfully.
  3. What the customers getMaju and Sinar do not receive a retail CBDC balance in this model.

Bank B → Sinar

  1. BeforeSinar’s deposit claim: RM40.
  2. CreditRaise its claim on Bank B by RM100.
  3. AfterSinar’s deposit claim: RM140. Total customer deposits stay at RM340.
A teaching example adapted from the non-bearer design in Garratt and Shin, BIS Bulletin 73 (11 April 2023), Graph 3. The views are the authors’ own. The banks and companies are made up. The example assumes enough money in each account, one currency and no fees. It is not a live Malaysian trial or a retail CBDC transaction.5

Costs, risks and deposit protection

Ask for the total cost of buying, sending, redeeming and converting the token. The blockchain or network fee may be only one part. Providers may also charge:

  • a spread (the gap between the buying and selling price);
  • a transaction fee;
  • a redemption fee; or
  • a fee for paying out to your bank.

A token pegged to the US dollar also leaves a Malaysian holder exposed to the dollar–ringgit exchange rate. For example, if the ringgit gets stronger, the same dollar token converts into fewer ringgit. This guide gives no current price, fee rate or investment return.7

What can go wrong

These things can affect each kind of token in different ways:6

  • the quality of the reserves, and access to them;
  • whether the issuer can pay its debts (solvency);
  • mistakes in the contract code;
  • how safely the keys are kept;
  • bridges (tools that move tokens between blockchains);
  • middlemen (intermediaries); and
  • system outages.

A reserve report alone does not prove that every holder has a claim that can be enforced ahead of others. Nor does it prove that holders can get cash at once. A direct claim on a central bank changes the credit risk, which is the risk that the issuer cannot pay. But service outages, scams and misuse can still hurt users.4

Deposit insurance (PIDM)

PIDM (Perbadanan Insurans Deposit Malaysia) protects eligible deposits up to RM250,000 per depositor at each member bank. Islamic and conventional deposits have separate limits under its rules. PIDM adds together eligible balances of the same kind at the same bank. It does not cover investment accounts or investment products.9 Calling something a token does not create an extra protection limit.

Here is a made-up example. Aina has RM200,000 in Islamic savings at one bank. Suppose she also holds RM100,000 of that bank’s tokenised deposits, and both count as eligible Islamic deposits. Her total of RM300,000 is then protected only up to RM250,000.

For a tokenised-deposit offer, ask for its actual deposit type, the member bank’s name and its protection disclosure. PIDM’s general page does not confirm whether the three DAIH projects are eligible. No one should describe stablecoins or CBDCs as PIDM-protected deposits just because they are digital money.9

Who can use them, and what about Shariah?

Muslim and non-Muslim readers both need to know the actual access conditions. Being able to hold or receive a token is one thing. Being eligible for these is another:

  • a bank service;
  • redemption with the issuer; or
  • a controlled test for institutions.

The DAIH is for firms developing new solutions, under their approved test arrangements. It is not a place where the public can apply for an account.2 Circle Mint’s limits exist because it serves businesses and distributors. It is not a Muslim-only service.8

Shariah

For Muslim readers, turning something into a token does not by itself make it Shariah-compliant. Nor does it make it non-compliant. What matters is:

  • the deposit or other contract behind it;
  • the reserve assets;
  • the holder’s rights;
  • how it is exchanged; and
  • any separate activity that pays a return.

The SC’s Shariah Advisory Council (SAC) has issued a ruling on digital assets. It applies only to assets that the SC regulates. It also treats digital currency backed by real currency as a separate case, under the rules on exchanging currencies.11

BNM’s February 2026 notice says some of the test uses will explore Shariah questions. That is not approval of any particular stablecoin, deposit token or CBDC.3 This guide explains what existing sources cover. It gives no new Shariah ruling.

Six checks before you buy or accept a token

  • Find out exactly who the issuer is, which country’s law applies (jurisdiction), what the product is and which provider is authorised.
  • Find your claim in writing. Who owes what, to whom, and what happens if something fails?
  • Check the reserves or the deposit behind the token. A reserve report (attestation) is not the same as your own legal rights.
  • Follow redemption or sale all the way to money you can spend. Check who is eligible, the currency, the fees and the settlement conditions.
  • Confirm the protection and complaint routes for that exact product. Don’t assume them from a token’s name.
  • Label news correctly. Exploration, a controlled test, a product you can use and a rule in force each need different proof.

Sources and scope

We checked these sources on 6 October 2026. BNM’s October 2025 discussion paper explores ideas; its February and July 2026 records describe tests. Circle is named only as an example of a foreign provider. It is not a recommendation, and it does not mean Circle is approved in Malaysia. BIS ideas and research are credited to their authors, within the limits of what they cover. Our translations of the sources are our own explanations, not versions approved by the issuers.

Search ISRA.my

Search guides, glossary terms, research records and publications.