Skip to content

Conference paper

International Shariah Scholars Forum (ISSF) 2016: trading, ownership and obligations

Use this source to ask what happens behind a securities trade: which rules apply, whether the seller can deliver, and what an arrangement obliges each party to do. The matched 2016 paper is available externally. The plain-language questions and later-document comparisons below are newly written, not an updated edition of the author’s work.

Sources checked 6 October 2026

Exact original title

Processes and Legal Requirements of Selected Practices on Platforms for Trading of Financial Papers and Their Instruments

By Engku Rabiah Adawiah Engku Ali. The mirror’s cover records the 11th International Shariah Scholars Forum, 1–2 November 2016, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; the inner title adds “binti” in the author’s name. The external PDF has a cover and 36 numbered paper pages. [P16]

Hands hold an open book with pink and green sticky notes.
Illustrative image only; the book shown is not the publication discussed.

What the paper actually covers

The author surveys Malaysia’s regulatory/platform setting, then concentrates on regulated short selling (RSS) and securities borrowing and lending (SBL). She compares differing Shariah positions and recommends further study; detailed fiqh analysis and derivatives are outside the main treatment. This historical discussion is not a present transaction verdict. [P16: §§1–4]

In her 2016 account, Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) covers banking/money-market instruments and infrastructure such as FAST for tendering and RENTAS for settlement; Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) covers capital-market regulation, with Bursa rules covering exchange trading, clearing and depository processes. This describes the paper’s historical division of functions, not a single retail platform or a complete current institutional map. [P16: §§1–2, pp.1–19]

The paper compares three historical positions. Regulated short selling (RSS) is a sale made under specific market rules; securities borrowing and lending (SBL) is the separate arrangement used to borrow securities.

AAOIFI position described by the author

The author reports that AAOIFI objected to selling shares without ownership and risk, and to treating securities lending as a loan (qard) or lease (ijarah). She says AAOIFI distinguished lending for use (i‘arah) for a pledge or for passing the shares’ profit to the borrower, with resale limited to enforcing the pledge.

Historical SC Shariah Advisory Council approach described by the author

The paper describes a lease-based SBL model that allowed resale with the owner’s consent. It also describes RSS backed by SBL as a way to improve the ability to deliver the securities and reduce uncertainty (gharar).

Separate BNM Shariah Advisory Council arrangement

The paper describes an i‘arah arrangement in which borrowed securities are used as collateral. The author states that this arrangement was not intended to support RSS.

These are the author’s account of historical positions, not a new ruling by this page or a statement about the current AAOIFI standards. She recommends reviewing the arguments against actual market practice.

Source: P16, section 3.4, pages 31–35.

Separate a share purchase from a borrowing obligation

New explanation using dated SC material: in conventional SBL, securities move to a borrower for a limited period against collateral; the lender earns a fee or return described in the arrangement. The borrower must return equivalent securities in number, not simply their old ringgit value. A short sale adds a sale to another buyer; the later cost of obtaining securities can rise. SBL can also serve purposes beyond a short sale. [SC08: p.2]

For a Malaysian reader, the useful distinction is between buying a share and taking on a duty to return securities. Cash received from a sale does not erase that duty. Collateral is security for obligations, not a promise that market prices will be favourable. The diagram is a simplified historical mechanism, not a set of instructions for opening a trading position.

The SC/Bursa 2009 SBLNT announcement limited direct borrowing/lending to eligible persons approved by Bursa Malaysia Securities Clearing, with specified securities and purposes and reporting through onshore representatives. Reading a public document does not itself confer trading access. Muslim and non-Muslim readers can examine this record; their actual access and chosen Islamic/conventional arrangement must be checked with the provider and applicable rules. No religion-based access decision is made here. [SC09: framework and reporting]

Visual 1

The delivery question behind a short sale

  1. Securities holder → borrowerTemporary securities transfer; collateral and agreed remuneration.
  2. Borrower → market buyerA short sale transfers securities to a buyer; cash proceeds go to the seller.
  3. Borrower → securities holderEquivalent securities must be returned; the old ringgit value alone does not discharge the obligation.
Full text description

The holder transfers securities to a borrower against collateral and agreed remuneration. A short sale sends securities to a market buyer and cash to the seller. The borrower remains responsible for returning equivalent securities; the repurchase price may differ. Approved participation and reporting are separate requirements.

This simplified historical diagram shows why a short seller must still return equivalent securities. It is not the later iSSB-NT model, a guide to opening an account or a Shariah ruling.

Sources: the 2016 paper, pages 20–21 and 29–31; SC’s 2008 explanation, page 2; SC and Bursa’s 2009 participation and reporting announcement.

Later documents must stay separate

The SC’s 31 December 2023 compilation describes an Islamic Securities Selling and Buying-Negotiated Transaction (iSSB-NT) model as an alternative to conventional SBLNT: two outright sales, with promises, a contractual cancellation option and collateral. The SAC resolved the proposed model permissible. That is an attributed resolution about a specified model, not a conclusion that any securities loan or short sale is acceptable. It is later context, not a finding added to the 2016 paper. [SC23: printed p.39]

SC Technical Note 3/2017 describes the first sale as deferred-payment and the later sale back as cash-payment through set-off. It allows omission of contract notes for ISSBNT only with rule compliance, system reporting and maintained trade-information records. The parties still supply trade confirmations through their licensed intermediaries. A missing contract note under that conditional exception does not mean an undocumented trade. [SC17: paras 5–7]

Another example of date-sensitive reading: the 2023 compilation discusses ordinary Bursa share settlement on T+2. Do not carry an older settlement timetable into today’s transaction. T means trade day; check the broker’s current settlement calendar and cut-off times. The SC’s live resolutions catalogue, accessed 6 October 2026, includes later updates beyond the 2023 compilation. Neither that compilation nor this page is a complete current rulebook. [SC23: printed pp.161–162] [SC catalogue]

Visual 2

What is established, and by which document?

  1. 2016 paper • original scopeRegulatory overview → RSS/SBL → differing Shariah positions → further study.
  2. 2017 / 2023 • later documentsSC17: sale/set-off and conditional documentation exception. SC23: specified iSSB-NT resolution and T+2 context.
  3. Today • verify the actual arrangementProvider agreement, charges, rights, current rules and access. These are new editorial questions, not facts verified for a broker.
Full text description

The original 2016 discussion is mapped separately from the 2017 documentation note and 2023 resolutions. Present offer terms and personal access remain to be checked. The third branch is new editorial guidance, not a finding attributed to the author.

P16 establishes the historical paper’s scope. Later SC originals supply separate context. Neither a paper title nor a general resolution verifies an individual trade. Read the full external paper and current applicable documents. [P16] [SC17] [SC23] [SCCAT]
Hands hold a calculator and write in a notebook beside a laptop and yellow folder.
Illustrative image only; it does not establish product terms, eligibility or outcomes.

Questions about costs and rights

New checklist for reading an actual offer: ask for brokerage and transaction charges, the securities-borrowing or equivalent contractual charge, collateral amount and valuation, how additional collateral is demanded, and any recall or early-close costs. Ask who receives distributions and voting rights during the arrangement, what replacement payments are due, and what happens if securities cannot be returned. A fee quote needs its charging base, period and taxes; a historical discussion cannot supply a current tariff.

We have not verified a present broker offer or its full agreement. This record does not verify the current Bursa rulebook or a present ISSBNT agreement. There are therefore no provider-specific rates, minimum collateral, eligibility promises or personal Shariah/suitability conclusions on this page. A Muslim reader seeking an Islamic arrangement should request the exact contractual model and applicable Shariah basis; a non-Muslim reader needs the same clarity on cost, rights and obligations.

Three common misreadings

  • “The share is Shariah-compliant, so every trading technique is covered.” Read the instrument, transaction contract and relevant ruling separately. The iSSB-NT resolution identifies a particular model.
  • “SBL and ISSBNT are just different names.” The cited 2017 technical note describes selling/buying transactions; it should not be silently rewritten as an ordinary loan.
  • “A 2016 platform paper validates my app.” The record is historical research. It does not verify a current platform, its licence, your access or a promised return.

New Malaysian example: if a broker offers to use shares you hold, ask whether this is conventional lending or an Islamic sale-and-buying arrangement. Read the signed agreement for the movement of securities, payment/set-off and the obligations that remain. Do not decide from the app’s label alone. [SC17] [SC23: p.39]

Bundles of papers are stacked on metal shelves.
Illustrative image only; the papers shown are not the historical records discussed.

How to use and cite this source

Read the external paper for its original discussion and citations. Use the exact title, author, forum and year, and cite the relevant page when referring to an argument. Identify the linked copy as an IEFpedia copy rather than presenting this summary as a new ISRA paper. The original event download is unavailable, so the linked external copy could not be compared directly with it. Treat it as a matching copy, not a restored original download.

For present decisions, obtain the provider’s dated agreement and disclosures, verify the operator and activity through the applicable regulator, and consult the current rule/resolution for the specific mechanism. The investing guide below offers a reading path; the blockchain guide helps distinguish an electronic ownership record from the right it records. These guides provide practical context; the paper does not analyse blockchain.

References

Original sources are linked externally. All checks accessed 6 October 2026. These summaries are newly written and are not institutional approval.

Search ISRA.my

Search guides, glossary terms, research records and publications.